Share this article and save a life!

💥 Everyone calls the ACA enrollment crash a fraud story.
The people who left did not commit fraud. They just ran out of money.

📰 According to KFF Health News, ACA plan enrollment continues to drop after Congress allowed enhanced ACA subsidies to expire. Insurers say they are expecting to hike premiums even more next year. And many Americans are publicly saying they can no longer afford coverage. The Trump administration, for its part, attributes the enrollment drop to a crackdown on fraud.

🎯 That framing is a political escape hatch, and I am done watching people accept it. When the price of something doubles and people stop buying it, we do not call that a demand problem. We call it a pricing problem. Congress made a deliberate choice to let those subsidies expire. Americans are not disappearing from the rolls because they were gaming the system. They are disappearing because the math stopped working for them.

📊 Here is what makes this worse. Insurers are not absorbing the loss. They are passing it through and then some. Enrollment drops, the risk pool gets sicker, premiums climb, more people drop off, premiums climb again. This is not a market correction. It is a spiral. And every insurer announcing next year’s hike is, in effect, announcing that the people who just got priced out made the right call. You cannot afford this. We agree. Please exit.

🤔 The counterpoint I hear: premiums were rising before the subsidies expired, and some of the enrollment gains were driven by loose eligibility rules that let people who did not qualify slip through. Fine. I will grant there was noise in the enrollment data. But that is an argument for tighter verification, not for letting the whole subsidy structure collapse and then blaming the fallout on the people who left. You do not fix a leaky faucet by demolishing the plumbing.

🏥 Meanwhile, KFF Health News also reports that Republicans and some Democrats on Capitol Hill are now taking aim at nonprofit hospitals, questioning whether they are delivering enough community benefit to justify their tax-exempt status. That is a fight worth having. But if we are asking hospitals to prove their community value, we should also be asking what community value looks like when the people those hospitals are supposed to serve have just been priced off their insurance.

🔥 Coverage is not a privilege you earn by being a low enough fraud risk. It is the floor of a functioning healthcare system, and right now we are actively sawing through it.

❓ To every CFO at a major insurer announcing premium hikes for next year: at what enrollment number does this become your problem too, not just the patients’?

👉 Follow Jonathan Govette, CEO of Oatmeal Health, for daily healthcare insights on LinkedIn. Deeper dives in The Oatmeal Bite on Substack: https://news.oatmealhealth.com

Share this article and save a life!

Author:


Guest post on Oatmeal Health and reach millions of healthcare professionals. Tell us your story!

Recent Posts